Conflicts of Interest and Commitment
Policy governing Conflicts of Interest and Commitment at Iowa State University is found at the Iowa State University Policy Library.
Conflicts of interest and commitment, or perceptions of conflicts of interest and commitment, can occur in a variety of forms. These pages are devoted to the management of situations that can arise when university employees have any external activity, significant financial interest, or management role that has the potential to:
- negatively impact objectivity in the execution of university duties (a “conflict of interest”), or
- reduce the time and attention an employee can devote to their university responsibilities, and thus negatively impact their performance or assigned university duties (a “conflict of commitment”)
These conflicts are a normal part of an active and vibrant university. With the increasing emphasis of universities on outreach and economic development, more university personnel are becoming involved with external entities or starting their own companies. The university strongly encourages these activities. However, they bring with them conflicts of interest and commitment or perceptions of conflicts of interest and commitment that need management to avoid harm to the persons or entities involved.
The negative impacts of unmanaged or inadequately managed conflicts of interest and commitment or perceived conflicts of interest and commitment can include:
- The use or perception of use of state resources for personal benefit or the benefit of immediate family members.
- The use or perception of use of the employee's university position to influence university business in a way that benefits one's self or immediate family members.
- Confusion in the ownership of intellectual property.
- Questions about the integrity of one's university research or scholarly activity.
- Harm to vulnerable populations, such as graduate students and research subjects.
Perceived conflicts of interest and commitment can be as harmful as real conflicts of interest and commitment. The university manages both by the disclosure of the conflict (or perceived conflict) followed by the creation of a Conflict of Interest Management Plan that specifies how the individual will keep their non-university activities from causing harm.
Disclosure and management are needed whether the non-university relationship is with a for-profit entity, a not-for-profit entity, or a charitable foundation. For example, it is a conflict of interest for a researcher to accept a grant from a non-profit foundation in which they have a management role. It is also a conflict of interest to accept grant funds from an external entity for which one consults.
All university employees are required to disclose potential conflicts of interest and commitment whether they think they have a conflict or not. The disclosures must be made prior to initiating the activity, annually, and whenever the employee’s situation changes. The appropriate method of disclosure varies with the type of activity as described in the Procedures, Applications, and Guidance document (PDF, 317KB).
The information disclosed will be forwarded to the individual's department chair/unit director, and then to representatives of the Senior Vice President and Provost to evaluate the situation. If a conflict of interest is possible, they will contact the individual to arrange further discussions and, if needed, develop an appropriate Conflict of Interest Management Plan.
Other related resources:
- Sponsored projects
- Family relationships
- Consenting relationships
- ISU Extension and Outreach COIC Policy (PDF, 318KB)
Contact for more information:
- ISU Conflicts of Interest and Commitment Policy: Office of Research Ethics, Vice President for Research, Phone: (515) 294-7793, E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org.
- Conflicts of Interest and Commitment in Research or Sponsored Funding: Office of Research Ethics, Vice President for Research, Phone: (515) 294-7793, E-mail: email@example.com.
- Conflicts of Interest in Procurement: Director of Procurement Services, Phone: (515) 294-2591, E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org.