Peer review
Iowa State University’s post-tenure review process is meant to assess the quality of a faculty member's performance in the areas of teaching, research/creative activities, extension/professional practice, and institutional service as indicated in the faculty member’s Position Responsibility Statement (PRS) in effect during the period of the review. This review must occur at least every seven years and include an overall assessment of the faculty member’s performance.
Information is provided to assist colleges, departments, and faculty members. The goal is to outline post-tenure review policies, practices, and expectations. Departments/schools are charged with developing and implementing a plan for peer review of each tenured faculty member (Faculty Handbook 5.3.4). Faculty, department chairs/school directors, and deans are responsible for familiarizing themselves with the Faculty Handbook policy (Faculty Handbook 5.3.4).
The deadline for college submission to the Office of the Senior Vice President and Provost is April 1. If the deadline falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or University holiday, nominations are due the next business day.
Guidance documents:
- Process Guidelines and Best Practices for Post-Tenure Review Materials (DOC)
- Faculty Handbook Policy (DOC)
- Cover Sheet (DOC)
- Checklist (optional) (DOC)
Best practices for post-tenure review instructional video
By the end of the Best Practices for Post-Tenure Review Instructional Video, viewers will be able to--
1. Explain the purpose, policies, and procedures governing Iowa State University's post-tenure review process, including the role of Position Responsibility Statements (PRSs), review timelines, outcomes, and institutional expectations.
2. Identify and apply best practices for conducting fair, evidence-based post-tenure reviews, including the evaluation of faculty accomplishments within the context of assigned responsibilities and disciplinary standards.
3. Recognize potential cognitive errors and conflicts of interest that can affect reviewer judgment and implement strategies to promote objectivity and consistency in post-tenure review decisions.
College templates for post-tenure review:
- Agriculture and Life Sciences
- Ivy College of Business (DOC)
- Design
- Engineering
- Health and Human Sciences
- Liberal Arts and Sciences - No college-level template
- Veterinary Medicine - No college-level template